In this comparison of HPSM vs ServiceNow we do a comprehensive examination of the key differences, similarities, pros, cons, and usage scenarios for two leading IT service management platforms. This article provides insights and detailed comparisons to help organizations choose the best fit for their needs, covering deployment models, customization options, scalability, and user experience.

Table of Contents

What is the Main Difference Between HPSM and ServiceNow?

The main difference between HPSM and ServiceNow is that HPSM, short for HP Service Manager, is traditionally an on-premises solution tailored for large enterprises, whereas ServiceNow is a cloud-based platform designed to be versatile for various business sizes. This fundamental distinction influences their deployment, maintenance, scalability, and cost considerations.

What is HPSM and What is ServiceNow?

HPSM (HP Service Manager) is an IT service management software solution developed by Hewlett-Packard. It supports comprehensive IT services and processes as defined by ITIL (Information Technology Infrastructure Library) standards. HPSM is best known for its robust functionality in incident management, problem management, change management, and service level management. This solution is generally implemented on-premises, granting organizations full control over their ITSM operations but also requiring substantial initial investment and ongoing infrastructure maintenance.

ServiceNow is a leading cloud-based IT service management platform. It offers a wide range of IT services, including incident management, change management, asset management, and more, all within a unified suite. ServiceNow’s software-as-a-service (SaaS) deployment model minimizes the need for extensive on-premises infrastructure, providing flexibility and lower upfront costs. Besides ITSM, ServiceNow extends its capabilities into enterprise service management (ESM), covering HR, finance, and other business functions.

Key Differences Between HPSM and ServiceNow

Deployment: HPSM is generally on-premises, requiring dedicated hardware and IT resources, whereas ServiceNow is cloud-based, eliminating the need for extensive physical infrastructure.
Customization: HPSM provides deep customization options for specific IT processes; ServiceNow, while also customizable, excels in ease of use and rapid deployment.
Scalability: ServiceNow effortlessly scales with growing business requirements due to its SaaS model; HPSM’s scalability might involve more complex adjustments and hardware upgrades.
Cost Structure: HPSM typically involves high initial costs due to on-premises setup, contrasted with ServiceNow’s subscription-based pricing, which spreads costs over time.
Support and Maintenance: HPSM requires internal IT teams for regular maintenance, while ServiceNow handles updates and maintenance centrally as a part of its service.
Upgrades: ServiceNow offers seamless, frequent updates with minimal disruption; HPSM upgrades can be more time-consuming and disruptive to implement.
Integration: ServiceNow often provides broader and more straightforward integrations with other cloud-based applications compared to HPSM.
User Interface: ServiceNow is recognized for its modern and intuitive user interface, which provides a better user experience out-of-the-box compared to HPSM’s more traditional interface.
Mobile Accessibility: ServiceNow offers robust mobile capabilities, allowing users to access services on-the-go. HPSM might need additional customization for similar mobile functionality.

Key Similarities Between HPSM and ServiceNow

ITIL Compliance: Both HPSM and ServiceNow are designed in accordance with ITIL standards, promoting best practices in IT service management.
Incident and Problem Management: Each platform offers comprehensive tools for managing incidents and resolving problems efficiently.
Change Management: Both solutions provide mechanisms to handle changes within IT environments systematically, reducing potential risks and impacts.
Service Catalog: HPSM and ServiceNow feature a service catalog, enabling users to request services and manage service workflows.
Reporting and Analytics: Detailed reporting and analytics are available in both platforms, helping businesses gain insights into service performance and areas for improvement.
Automation Capabilities: Both HPSM and ServiceNow offer automation features to streamline various ITSM processes, enhancing efficiency and reducing manual efforts.
Asset Management: Each platform includes asset management tools that help in tracking and managing IT assets throughout their lifecycle.

Explore GetResponses current deals-click here

Pros of HPSM Over ServiceNow

Control Over Data: HPSM allows organizations to maintain complete control over their data with on-premises deployment.
Customization: HPSM offers extensive customization, which can be tailored to meet specific business processes and workflows.
Security: Being on-premises, HPSM can offer heightened security measures tailored to the organization’s unique needs.
Dependency: There’s no reliance on third-party cloud providers, providing full autonomy over service management operations.
Compliance: On-premises deployment helps organizations comply with specific regulatory requirements that cloud services may not meet.
Integration: HPSM can be seamlessly integrated with other on-premises enterprise applications and systems.
Performance: As an on-premises solution, HPSM can be optimized for high performance within the existing IT environment.

Cons of HPSM Compared to ServiceNow

Initial Costs: The initial setup of HPSM can be expensive due to the need for servers and other hardware.
Maintenance: Ongoing maintenance and upgrades must be managed by the internal IT team, increasing workload and costs.
Scalability: Scaling HPSM might require significant investment in additional hardware and resources.
User Experience: HPSM’s user interface is less intuitive compared to ServiceNow, potentially leading to higher training needs.
Mobile Accessibility: HPSM often lacks out-of-the-box mobile functionality, requiring additional customization.
Update Frequency: Software updates and improvements for HPSM occur less frequently and can disrupt service during implementations.

Pros of ServiceNow Over HPSM

Cost Efficiency: ServiceNow’s subscription-based pricing model reduces the need for large upfront investments.
Ease of Deployment: ServiceNow’s cloud-based nature allows for easy and rapid deployment without extensive hardware needs.
Maintenance: Maintenance and updates are managed by ServiceNow, freeing internal IT teams from these tasks.
Scalability: ServiceNow scales effortlessly with organizational growth, requiring no extra physical infrastructure.
User Interface: The interface of ServiceNow is modern and user-friendly, reducing the learning curve for new users.
Integration: ServiceNow offers extensive, straightforward integrations with a variety of cloud-based and on-premises solutions.
Mobile Support: ServiceNow provides robust mobile app capabilities, enabling access to services from anywhere.

Cons of ServiceNow Compared to HPSM

Data Residency: Some organizations may have concerns over data residency as ServiceNow is a cloud-based solution.
Customization Limits: While ServiceNow is highly customizable, certain deeply specific customizations may be more challenging compared to HPSM.
Subscription Costs: Over time, ServiceNow’s subscription-based model can become costly as user numbers and service demands grow.
Network Dependence: ServiceNow’s performance relies on internet connectivity and network quality, which can be a limiting factor.
Vendor Dependence: Businesses are dependent on ServiceNow for maintenance and updates, which might introduce risks associated with vendor reliability.
Security Measures: Though ServiceNow offers robust security, some organizations might find cloud-based security less transparent compared to traditional on-premises solutions.

Situations When HPSM is Better than ServiceNow

Data Sensitivity: Organizations that require strict data control and prefer on-premises solutions will find HPSM more suitable.
Legacy Systems: Companies with complex, legacy systems might benefit from HPSM’s deeper customization options and on-premises integration capabilities.
Regulatory Compliance: HPSM is ideal for businesses that must adhere to stringent compliance and regulatory requirements that cloud solutions may not meet.
Highly Customized Processes: Enterprises needing highly specific IT service management workflows and processes might find HPSM’s flexibility beneficial.
Control Over Upgrades: HPSM allows organizations to control the timing and impact of software upgrades, preventing potential disruptions.
Security Concerns: For organizations prioritizing internal security measures and avoiding external dependencies, the on-premises nature of HPSM provides peace of mind.
Internal IT Expertise: Organizations with strong internal IT departments capable of handling maintenance, upgrades, and customizations may prefer HPSM.

Situations When ServiceNow is Better than HPSM

Rapid Deployment: Businesses needing quick, hassle-free deployment can benefit from ServiceNow’s cloud-based setup.
Scalability Needs: Enterprises anticipating growth and scalability requirements will find ServiceNow’s cloud model more adaptable.
Lower Upfront Costs: ServiceNow’s subscription model suits businesses looking to avoid high initial investments in hardware and infrastructure.
Frequent Updates: Organizations seeking regular updates and new features without disrupting their operations will prefer ServiceNow.
Mobile Workforce: ServiceNow’s robust mobile features support businesses with employees who need to access services from anywhere.
Ease of Use: Companies prioritizing ease of use and intuitive interface tend to favor ServiceNow’s modern design.
Third-Party Integration: ServiceNow is beneficial for businesses needing extensive integrations with other cloud-based tools and services.

See GetResponses current prices-click here

Features of HPSM vs Features of ServiceNow

Incident Management: Both platforms offer comprehensive tools, but ServiceNow provides a more user-friendly interface.
Change Management: HPSM is highly customizable for specific organizational processes; ServiceNow excels in ease of use and faster deployment.
Customization Options: HPSM allows deeper customization capabilities, while ServiceNow balances customization with ease of implementation.
Service Catalog: Both platforms include this feature, but ServiceNow’s catalog is more visually appealing and easier for end-users.
Reporting and Analytics: ServiceNow offers real-time analytics and intuitive dashboards compared to HPSM’s more traditional reporting tools.
Mobile Accessibility: ServiceNow provides robust mobile support out-of-the-box, while HPSM may require additional customizations.
Automation: Both platforms include robust automation features, although ServiceNow’s user-friendly interface simplifies creating automation workflows.
Integration: ServiceNow often offers broader integration options with cloud-based applications, while HPSM excels in on-premises integrations.

Implementation Considerations for HPSM and ServiceNow

When deciding between HPSM and ServiceNow, it’s important to consider how each solution aligns with your organization’s needs. Whether your focus is on cost, deployment model, or specific ITSM features, both platforms offer distinct advantages and challenges. Making an informed choice will depend on several critical factors outlined below.

Financial Implications

Initial costs for each platform vary significantly. HPSM typically involves a sizable upfront investment, primarily due to the need for on-premises infrastructure and continuous maintenance. This can be a deterrent for organizations with limited capital expenditure budgets. In contrast, ServiceNow adopts a subscription-based model, spreading the expenses over time. While this might seem more appealing initially, it’s crucial to weigh the long-term subscription costs which can accumulate significantly as user numbers grow.

On the other hand, operational costs also differ. Running HPSM requires dedicated IT staff to manage and maintain the system. This includes handling updates, security patches, and hardware. ServiceNow, being cloud-based, largely removes this burden as the provider handles most maintenance tasks. Nevertheless, understanding these cost implications can help in assessing the true value of each platform over its lifecycle.

Technical Environment Compatibility

The technical environment of your organization plays a significant role in choosing between HPSM and ServiceNow. HPSM, being an on-premises solution, might be more compatible with existing, legacy systems. It offers the flexibility of deep integration with other customized in-house applications. This is specifically beneficial for organizations operating in tightly controlled IT environments. Furthermore, having all systems domiciled in-house allows for quicker troubleshooting and adaptations, should the need arise.

Conversely, ServiceNow excels in environments that favor modern and agile IT infrastructures. With its extensive API capabilities and third-party integration support, ServiceNow can seamlessly connect with various current and cloud-based applications. This facilitates a smoother digital transformation journey, making it simpler for organizations to adopt new technologies. Notably, the adaptability and flexibility of ServiceNow’s integrations can offer longer-term advantages in an increasingly connected ecosystem.

Training and User Adoption

User adoption rates often depend on how intuitive a platform is. ServiceNow is known for its clean and modern interface, which simplifies the user experience. This interface reduces the need for extensive training and helps in faster adoption across various departments. Transitioning teams to ServiceNow can, therefore, be relatively smoother, minimizing downtime and accelerating productivity gains.

HPSM, with its more traditional interface, might present a steeper learning curve. Organizations may need to invest more in training sessions to ensure all employees are comfortable using the platform. While this might seem a disadvantage initially, the high level of customization HPSM offers can lead to workflows specifically tailored to the organization’s processes. This personalization can result in higher long-term efficiencies once the initial learning curve is overcome.

Future Trends in ITSM Solutions

Both HPSM and ServiceNow are continuously evolving to meet the changing demands of their users. Staying updated with these trends can help organizations make more strategic decisions regarding their ITSM solutions. Future advancements in these platforms promise to offer enhanced capabilities and smarter management.

Emphasis on Artificial Intelligence

The integration of AI in ITSM platforms is a growing trend. ServiceNow has been a frontrunner in this, incorporating AI-based features like virtual agents and predictive analytics to enhance user experience and efficiency. These AI tools can handle routine service requests, allowing IT staff to focus on more complex issues. Additionally, predictive analytics can provide insights that preempt potential problems, reducing downtime and improving service reliability.

HPSM is also anticipated to integrate more AI capabilities, albeit at a slower pace. The on-premises nature of HPSM might pose some limitations in leveraging cloud-based AI tools fully. Nevertheless, with tailored AI implementations, HPSM can still offer powerful enhancements for process automations and decision-making support within controlled environments, providing a competitive edge for businesses that require high customization levels.

Growth in Remote and Hybrid Work Environments

The rise of remote and hybrid work environments necessitates flexible and accessible ITSM solutions. ServiceNow’s cloud-based platform naturally supports this trend by providing access to IT services from any location with internet connectivity. Features such as mobile apps and remote support tools make it easier for employees to manage their IT needs irrespective of their physical location. This is increasingly important as businesses adopt more flexible working policies.

HPSM can also support remote work, but this often requires additional configurations and potential upgrades to existing infrastructure. On-premises solutions traditionally excel in secure, centralized environments but may need substantial adjustments to offer the same level of accessibility as cloud-based options. Effective planning and strategic investments can, however, enable HPSM to meet the demands of modern work setups.

Integration with Other Business Functions

Modern ITSM platforms are increasingly being integrated with other business functions beyond IT. ServiceNow, for example, extends its capabilities into areas such as HR, finance, and customer service, creating a comprehensive enterprise service management suite. This broader scope allows organizations to streamline operations across various departments, enhancing overall efficiency and providing a unified user experience.

HPSM traditionally focuses more on IT-specific functions. Still, with adequate customization, it can integrate with other business functions. Companies might need to invest more initially to achieve this cross-functional integration, but the resulting efficiencies can justify the investment. Utilizing HPSM in a wider enterprise context can make internal processes more coherent and reduce operational silos.

ccess GetResponses latest deals-click here

FAQs

Can HPSM and ServiceNow be used together?

Yes, some organizations use HPSM for certain processes and ServiceNow for others. This hybrid approach can leverage the strengths of both platforms, but it requires careful planning for integration and data management to avoid redundancies and ensure smooth operations.

How does the licensing structure differ between HPSM and ServiceNow?

HPSM usually requires a one-time license fee plus ongoing maintenance costs. ServiceNow, on the other hand, operates on a subscription-based model. The choice between these licensing structures depends on an organization’s budgeting preferences and long-term cost strategies.

Which platform offers better support for small to medium-sized businesses?

ServiceNow generally offers better support for small to medium-sized businesses due to its cloud-based, scalable model and simpler deployment process. Its intuitive interface and broad functionality make it accessible without needing extensive in-house IT expertise.

How do HPSM and ServiceNow handle data backup and recovery?

HPSM typically relies on the organization’s existing data backup and recovery systems as it is hosted on-premises. ServiceNow, being cloud-based, includes built-in data backup and recovery features managed by the service provider, aiming to deliver reliability and peace of mind.

What customization limitations exist with ServiceNow compared to HPSM?

ServiceNow, while highly customizable, might face restrictions when it comes to deeply complex customizations, mainly due to its cloud-based infrastructure. HPSM offers more extensive customization potential because of its on-premises nature, allowing for more intricate adjustments.

Can ServiceNow integrate with on-premises systems and applications?

Yes, ServiceNow can integrate with on-premises systems and applications, but it generally excels in connecting with other cloud-based services. This capability allows organizations to maintain some existing on-premises applications while adopting ServiceNow for broader IT service management needs.

Is transitioning from HPSM to ServiceNow a complex process?

Transitioning from HPSM to ServiceNow can be complex, depending on the extent of customizations and integration within the existing HPSM setup. It requires meticulous planning, data migration strategies, and potentially significant retraining for users to adapt to the new platform.

What are the primary security concerns when using a cloud-based platform like ServiceNow?

Security concerns with cloud-based platforms often revolve around data residency, compliance with regional data protection regulations, and dependency on third-party providers for security measures. ServiceNow addresses these concerns through stringent security protocols, but organizations must assess their own risk tolerance.

Do both platforms support ITIL processes?

Yes, both HPSM and ServiceNow support ITIL (Information Technology Infrastructure Library) processes. They are designed to align with ITIL best practices for managing IT services, including incident, problem, and change management.

HPSM vs ServiceNow Summary

HPSM and ServiceNow offer different strengths suited to various organizational needs. HPSM is ideal for companies that require on-premises control, deep customization, and have significant existing IT investments. Its traditional deployment and flexibility cater to specific use cases and environments demanding high security and compliance.

ServiceNow, with its cloud-based platform, excels in ease of deployment, scalability, and integration with modern applications. It is highly suitable for organizations looking to adopt agile practices, reduce operational overhead, and leverage advanced features like AI and mobile accessibility. ServiceNow’s user-friendly interface and frequent updates provide a dynamic, forward-thinking solution.

By thoroughly evaluating these factors, organizations can make well-informed decisions that align with their operational requirements and long-term strategic goals. Both platforms have their merits, and the choice ultimately depends on what aligns best with the organization’s unique context and future direction.

Criteria	HPSM	ServiceNow
Deployment	On-premises, requires hardware setup	Cloud-based, minimal hardware needed
Customization	Extensive and highly specific	Customizable but simpler for rapid deployment
Scalability	Requires significant hardware and resource investment	Easily scalable due to cloud infrastructure
Cost Structure	High initial costs with ongoing maintenance expenses	Subscription-based, lower initial costs but accumulates over time
Maintenance	Handled by internal IT	Managed by ServiceNow, reducing internal workload
User Interface	Traditional, may require more training	Modern, intuitive, easier for new users
Mobile Accessibility	Needs additional customization	Robust out-of-the-box mobile support
Integration	Seamless with on-premises systems	Broad integrations, especially with cloud services
Incident Management	Robust and detailed	Comprehensive with user-friendly interface
Security	Enhanced internal security measures	Strong cloud security but requires trust in provider
AI Capabilities	Limited integration	Integrated AI features like virtual agents and analytics
Data Backup and Recovery	Relies on internal policies	Built-in, managed by ServiceNow
Support for Remote Work	Needs configuration	Excellent out-of-the-box support
Regulatory Compliance	Better for stringent compliance needs	Meets most general compliance but dependent on cloud
Best Use Case	Large organizations with high customization needs	Agile businesses seeking scalability and modern features